Movie Parliament
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • This House
  • Articles
  • Foreign Affairs
    • Cannes 2017
    • Cannes2016
    • 2016 Oscars Predictions
    • 2015 César Awards
    • 2014 César Awards
    • 2014 French Bloggers Awards
    • Top10 2014
    • 2013 César Awards
    • 2013 Cannes Coverage
    • European Film Awards 2012
    • (50) Films of Summer
    • 2012 Cannes Coverage
    • 2011 César Awards
    • 2011 Cannes Coverage
  • Film History
    • Classic Films
    • Cult Movies
    • Foreign Masterpieces
  • Awards
    • Awards Decade 2011-2020
    • Awards2020
    • Awards2019
    • Awards2018
    • Awards2017
    • Awards2016
    • Awards2015
    • Awards 2014
    • Awards 2013
    • Awards 2012
    • Awards 2011 >
      • FYC - Best 2011 Film
  • Top 50 of the Decade
    • 2009
    • 2008
    • 2007
    • 2006
    • 2005
    • 2004
    • 2003
    • 2002
    • 2001
    • 2000
  • Summer Movie Wager
  • 2018 Most Anticipated

Only God Forgives

7/19/2013

1 Comment

 
Picture
Writer & Director: Nicolas Winding Refn 
Starring: Ryan Gosling, Kristin Scott Thomas and Vithaya Pansringarm


Review Written By: Michael Dalton (Prime Minister)

(This is the second review of this film to be posted on Movie Parliament. For a different take please read the review of our Minister for Foreign Affairs, Arnaud Trouvé here)

It is hard, if not impossible, to talk about Only God Forgives, without comparing it to Drive. The director (Nicolas Winding Refn), star (Ryan Gosling) and composer (Cliff Martinez) of Drive all reunite for Only God Forgives, a film that allegedly drew both booing and applauding following its first screening at the Cannes film festival. Julian (Ryan Gosling) runs a boxing ring in Bangkok as a cover for a drug operation alongside his brother Billy (Tom Burke). One night, Billy decides, ‘It’s time to meet the devil’ and proceeds to rape and kill a sixteen year old prostitute. A policeman named Chang (Vithaya Pansringarm) allows the prostitute’s father to take bloody revenge on Billy, making both men a target of Julian and Billy’s evil mother (Played by Kristin Scott Thomas) who arrives in Thailand to grieve and through her youngest Julian, avenge her first born son.

Drive is one of my favourite films of all time and swept the first ever Movie Parliament awards. Therefore I had high expectations for Only God Forgives, however had been well informed to not expect a sequel to Drive. Drive was an arthouse film that became a cult classic and touched upon part of the mainstream audience that until then had been unfamiliar with the work of Nicolas Winding Refn. It takes a film like Only God Forgives, to demonstrate exactly why it was that Drive was so beloved and why a film like Drive works the way it does. At its core, Drive is a romantic superhero movie and Only God Forgives makes Drive look like the warm, fuzzy hug that film really is. Forgives is a much nastier and more ambiguous film than Drive.

As is to be expected from Nicolas Winding Refn, Only God Forgives looks fantastic. The cinematography by Larry Smith is moody, haunting and echoes the beauty and brutality of the film. The production design by Beth Mickle is also worthy of notation, from the hellish halls of the boxing ring, to the humble farmhouse of Chang and the modern skyscraper of a hotel, in which perhaps the film’s true villain resides. Refn is a pure and true filmmaker, in the sense that he elects and prefers to tell much of his story through visuals and music. This approach that results in some rather muted performances, particularly by Ryan Gosling, can be found artsy, pretentious, self-indulgent and infuriating by some. Yet refreshing, admirable and even soothing by others. However whatever you may think of the film’s story and performances, there is no doubting that on a visual level, this is one of the year’s more accomplished and memorable films.

The story is just as simple as Drive’s yet much bloodier and in a sense, much more challenging. Refn blurs the lines of reality in this film in a way he didn’t in Drive (Or at least does it much more overtly here) leading one to question what is actually happening and what may be playing out in Julian’s evidently disturbed mind. There is clearly much symbolism on display here that warrants repeat viewings, with much foreshadowing present in the first act in retrospect. Essays could be written about what characters in this film represent, with this film, like Drive, having more density than many will give it credit for. I haven’t put all the pieces of the puzzle together yet, but it’s all about Ryan Gosling’s hands…

The film is perhaps the most violent I have seen all year, not in terms of the volume of violence but the brutality of it. There is one scene in particular that is one of the more gruesome and disturbing pieces of violence I have seen in a cinema, creating an audible and visual reaction amongst my audience. Some may find the violence problematic and perhaps weightless, however nobody can argue that Refn’s scenes of violence don’t effect you in some way and in my eyes, that is how a scene of violence should be handled and delivered.

Ryan Gosling gives a performance that is even more silent and subtle than his one in Drive. Some are growing tired of Gosling doing this kind of performance, however I personally continue to find it powerful and effective. Although perhaps it is because these recent performances of his are creating a shy boys fantasy, in which we can imagine our quietness is just as charismatic, mysterious and powerful as Gosling’s. As was noted by Arnaud in his review, Julian is not a heroic character and is worlds away from ‘The Driver’ Reminiscent of Norman Bates, Gosling’s Julian is a conflicted character who appears to think his brother got what he deserved, yet feels duty bound to follow the instructions of mother. When a Thai prostitute asks why Julian lets his mother speak to him the way she does, he reacts violently, grabbing her by the throat and saying, ‘Because she’s my mother’ There’s an implied incestuous relationship with the scenes between Gosling and Kristin Scott Thomas containing much underlying, unspoken tension. Scott Thomas has the film’s showiest performance as the mother, gifted the film’s most memorable and sickening lines. Upon learning that her eldest son raped and killed a sixteen year old her response is, ‘I’m sure he had his reasons’ Vitahaya Pansringarm is in many ways the star of the film as Chang. He has a silent, honourable strength and intimidation that lead him to dominate every scene he is in without having to mutter a word.

Ultimately Only God Forgives is a challenging, sickening film that is certainly not for everybody. It is slow and its 90 minute running time doesn’t fly by, whilst the moral ambiguity of all the characters doesn’t given the audience a traditional figure to latch onto. The violence is brutal and the story simple yet symbolically elusive, resulting in arguably a simultaneously shallow, superficial yet frustratingly unattainable experience in regards to narrative. It is for these reasons why many may struggle with and hate Only God Forgives. However I personally found the film to be among the best released so far this year, with it getting better and better as it progresses, reaching a conclusion that displayed and encapsulated the beauty and brutality of the film. It isn’t Drive, however accepted on its own terms, Only God Forgives is an interesting and memorable piece of work. 

Picture
Summary: Beautiful and brutal, Only God Forgives is stylish, challenging, memorable and divisive filmmaking.

Movie Parliament Rating: MAJORITY GOVERNMENT (What does this mean?)

By Movie Parliament Prime Minister,
Michael Dalton

Disagree with this review? Give us your thoughts in the comments below. 


1 Comment
BangorBoy
7/19/2013 06:06:33 am

I aggressively agree with this. As to trying to fit all the pieces of that puzzle together I think its trying to imply that Julian used to work as a .... Handyman...

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    Movie Parliament Prime Minister: Michael Dalton

    Minister for Foreign Affairs: Arnaud Trouve

    Minister for History: Leonhard Balk

    Archives

    March 2019
    October 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    January 2016
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    Brad Pitt
    Chris Hemsworth
    Dredd
    Film Review
    Gangster Film
    Kristen Stewart
    New Release
    Sci Fi
    Sci-fi

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.