Movie Parliament
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • This House
  • Articles
  • Foreign Affairs
    • Cannes 2017
    • Cannes2016
    • 2016 Oscars Predictions
    • 2015 César Awards
    • 2014 César Awards
    • 2014 French Bloggers Awards
    • Top10 2014
    • 2013 César Awards
    • 2013 Cannes Coverage
    • European Film Awards 2012
    • (50) Films of Summer
    • 2012 Cannes Coverage
    • 2011 César Awards
    • 2011 Cannes Coverage
  • Film History
    • Classic Films
    • Cult Movies
    • Foreign Masterpieces
  • Awards
    • Awards Decade 2011-2020
    • Awards2020
    • Awards2019
    • Awards2018
    • Awards2017
    • Awards2016
    • Awards2015
    • Awards 2014
    • Awards 2013
    • Awards 2012
    • Awards 2011 >
      • FYC - Best 2011 Film
  • Top 50 of the Decade
    • 2009
    • 2008
    • 2007
    • 2006
    • 2005
    • 2004
    • 2003
    • 2002
    • 2001
    • 2000
  • Summer Movie Wager
  • 2018 Most Anticipated

Why Prometheus is better than Alien: Covenant and Ridley Scott is the new George Lucas

5/19/2017

1 Comment

 
Picture
Director: Ridley Scott
Writers: John Logan and Dante Harper 
Starring: Katherine Waterston, Michael Fassbender, Billy Crudup and Danny McBride. 

Review Written By: Michael Dalton, Prime Minister
​When Prometheus was released in the summer of 2012 anticipation was high for Ridley Scott’s return to the Alien franchise. His 1979 original made a hero out of Sigourney Weaver and contained one of cinema’s most shocking scenes. The subsequent sequels tarnished the brand, resulting in the low point that was Alien vs. Predator. Prometheus was not only supposed to mark Ridley Scott’s return to the science-fiction genre, but also the franchise’s return to its bloody roots. However, Ridley Scott had other things on his mind, such as the meaning of life, and delivered a film that left people confused both by its tone and the dubious decisions of its characters. Despite its mixed reception, one thing that all reviews of Alien: Covenant seem to agree on is that it’s better than Prometheus. I disagree, and think that Alien: Covenant actually shows just what a good film Prometheus is. 

Prometheus, for all its flaws, at least had an air of originality. In fact, the film was so original that it would have been better served had it been its own entity, merely taking place in the Alien universe but not directly connected to the original. As an Alien movie it is disappointing. The Xenomorph hardly appears and, one sequence aside, it doesn’t contain any of the original’s visceral horror. However, what it does contain are some superb performances, principally from Michael Fassbender as the android David. The film also boasts some stunning imagery and production design, as well as dark and mature themes. In an industry that is devoid of big-budget, original science fiction, it’s reasonable to assume that had it arrived without the pressure of being an Alien prequel, the reception to Prometheus would have been much kinder. 
However, the reception wasn’t kind and Ridley Scott (or at least the studio) was listening. Marketing for Alien: Covenant has put the Xenomorph front and center and would almost have you believe that this film has nothing to do with Prometheus. And yet, as the film progresses it becomes clear that it wants to have its cake and eat it, revealing itself to be both a sequel to Prometheus as well as essentially a remake of Alien. It feels like two separate scripts were fused together and the result is a dishonest and disjointed mess. 

For somebody who’s called it, ‘the thinking man’s horror film’, Ridley Scott insults the audience’s intelligence in many ways throughout Alien: Covenant (No reference or allusion can be made without aggressive citation from the characters). However, perhaps the most galling is the film’s implicit suggestion that all we wanted was a by the numbers retread of Alien and some Xenomorph action. All of which is phoned in to disguise the film’s true intention, which is a doubling down on Prometheus. It defenestrates the film to try and gain some geek cred, yet also wholly embraces it. Not only that, it embraces its worst aspects, with Covenant’s script making Damon Lindelof’s words sound natural and subtle.  

For somebody considered an auteur director, Alien: Covenant is Ridley Scott filmmaking by focus group. To add bewildering insult to injury, it’s done to cynically dispose of a film whose style and plot it lovingly continues. And if that sounds like a contradiction it’s because it is. And so is this film. Either make Prometheus 2 or a true Alien prequel, all this disjointed mess serves to do is undermine what could have been an interesting sci-fi series in its own right, and further saturate the Alien franchise. You’d think if anybody could make the Xenomorph scary again it’s Ridley Scott and yet the film’s desire to explain the origins of that classic movie monster only serves to rob it of the qualities that made it so terrifying in the first place.
 
If you didn’t know, you wouldn’t think that this film was from the same director as Alien; such is its fundamental misunderstanding of what made that film so scary. Like George Lucas and Peter Jackson before him, in going back to provide his classic with a prequel trilogy, Ridley Scott seems to have forgotten what made his own film so good in the first place. Watching Alien: Covenant, the film I was most reminded of was not Alien, but rather Attack of the Clones. That film got good reviews just for not being The Phantom Menace, but that didn’t make it any good.
 
With this prequel series, Ridley Scott is following the George Lucas mold of providing utterly unnecessary backstory in the most ponderous of ways. To extend this Star Wars comparison further, Alien: Covenant represents the worst of both worlds, having the portent of the prequels and the pandering fan service of the latest sequels. However, whereas The Force Awakens was good, all the Alien moments here feel utterly generic and unspectacular. Who would have thought that a chest-bursting scene could feel like such a non-event?   
Picture
​Whilst Prometheus may not have lived up to its billing as an Alien prequel, it is a far more ambitious and original film than Alien: Covenant. The characters are better realized, with the crew of the Covenant being more disposable than the cast of a slasher movie. This is a point of view that the film itself agrees with, as despite Katherine Waterston’s great performance, Michael Fassbender’s David is the true protagonist. The film starts and ends with him, being his story more than anyone else’s. This would be fine if what we were watching was a straight-up sequel to Prometheus, but it’s fundamentally at odds with the Alien film it presents itself as and reduces all the other characters, and the time spent with them, to nothing.
 
Meanwhile, there is no sequence in Covenant as compelling, or disturbing, as the one in Prometheus where Noomi Rapace’s character has to perform self-surgery in order to remove an Alien fetus. Alien: Covenant may dial up the Xenomorph action but it doesn’t do so to any great effect. Whilst we all remember sequences from Alien, Aliens and Prometheus, I’d be willing to bet that in a few years time people will struggle to remember anything from Alien: Covenant. And perhaps that’s the film’s biggest crime beyond its dishonest disjointedness…it just isn’t scary. 

Closing Remarks 

Ultimately, Alien: Covenant is an unimaginative retread of Alien fused with a Prometheus sequel that dials up the portent and feels a need to justify its existence. The result is a hybrid so horrific, it challenges the monster that used to be at the centre of it all. 

Movie Parliament Rating: FRINGE PARTY
What do you think? Is Alien: Covenant a better film than Prometheus? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below. 

By Movie Parliament Prime Minister, 
Michael Dalton 
1 Comment
Moegreen
9/17/2017 11:28:33 am

Wholeheartedly agree. Scott has taken the coward's way out with Covenant. Prometheus had a sense of wonder about it. Also nuance. David is turned into a cartoon villain in Covenant. 2 dashes of Prometheus, 1 dash of Alien, 1 dash of Aliens and forget to add any art, or switch on the oven.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Authors

    Movie Parliament Prime Minister: Michael Dalton

    Minister for Foreign Affairs: Arnaud Trouve

    Minister for History: Leonhard Balk

    Archives

    March 2019
    October 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    January 2016
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012

    Categories

    All
    Brad Pitt
    Chris Hemsworth
    Dredd
    Film Review
    Gangster Film
    Kristen Stewart
    New Release
    Sci Fi
    Sci-fi

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.